Alberta vote rejects independence process, partial count shows about 77% to stay
In short
Alberta held a provincial vote on 19 October on whether to start a process toward leaving Canada. With more than 1 million ballots counted, about 77% backed staying and 23% backed starting the process, Yonhap said, citing AP. Reuters, quoted by Korea Economic Daily, reported that the proposal was rejected.
Read the full story 2 min read
Voters in Canada's Alberta province backed staying in Canada in a vote held on 19 October on whether to start a process toward independence. According to a preliminary count from Alberta's election body cited by AP, more than 1 million ballots had been counted by 20 October and about 77% supported staying, while 23% backed starting the independence process. Reuters, quoted by Korea Economic Daily, reported that the proposal was rejected. Yonhap described it as effectively rejected. [ 7 , 8 , 10 ]
Chosun Ilbo said CBC projected a remain victory when roughly a third of ballots had been counted, with 76% to 77% for staying. A separate Chosun Ilbo item said CBC put the remain share at 76.6% with more than a third counted. Chosun Ilbo said 1.35 million of 5.1 million voters, 43%, took part in early voting; Yonhap said early voting ran from 13 to 17 October. [ 8 , 9 , 10 ]
Premier Danielle Smith said on social media that Albertans chose a stronger Alberta within a united Canada. Yonhap said Smith opposes separation but held the vote under pressure from separatists in her ruling United Conservative Party. Chosun Ilbo said the prevailing analysis was that the vote was a political gamble to placate that faction, and that Canadian media reported she was criticised by both hardline separatists and federalists in the party. Carney said Albertans made a clear choice and chose Canada. [ 8 , 10 ]
The vote did not itself decide independence. The ballot had ten questions: nine on provincial powers such as immigration and constitutional change, and a tenth on starting the independence process. Had the majority voted yes, a separate legally binding vote would have followed on whether to begin the administrative process. [ 4 , 6 , 8 , 10 ]
Before the vote, polls showed low support for independence. Angus Reid found 66% of Alberta residents opposed it, Leger found 70% wanted to keep the status quo and 22% backed starting the process, and an Ipsos poll cited by Hankook Ilbo found 23% would vote for it. A petition that prompted the vote was signed by more than 300,000 people; Alberta has about 5 million residents. [ 4 , 5 , 6 ]
Outlets cited anger at federal carbon tax and environmental policies and at the use of Alberta's tax revenue to support other provinces. Carney, speaking in Calgary on 15 October, said the vote came at the worst time and that outside forces were trying to divide Canadians. He did not name the United States, Yonhap said. Dong-A Ilbo, citing the Financial Times, reported that separatist activist Jeff Rath met State Department officials three times; the State Department said it made no promises. [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 8 , 10 ]
Earlier in October the separatist Parti Quebecois won Quebec's provincial election, and Hankook Ilbo, citing Reuters, said it plans a third independence vote. Chosun Ilbo's summary said the dispute over Alberta's independence is expected to continue for the time being. [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 9 ]
Why it matters
Chosun Ilbo and Yonhap, citing AP, describe the result as a win for Prime Minister Mark Carney and supporters of Canadian unity at a time of tension with the United States. Korean outlets also note that the dispute may continue, and Quebec's separatist party has said it will hold a third independence vote.
Key facts
- Alberta held its vote on 19 October; early voting took place on 13 to 17 October. [ 4 , 10 ]
- Per a preliminary count from Alberta's election body cited by AP, more than 1 million ballots were counted and about 77% supported staying in Canada; 23% backed starting the independence process. [ 8 , 10 ]
- CBC reported that 76.6% backed staying with more than a third of the count done, according to Chosun Ilbo. [ 9 ]
- Reuters reported that the independence referendum was rejected. [ 7 ]
- A majority yes vote would have led to a separate, legally binding vote on whether to begin the administrative process for independence. [ 4 , 6 , 10 ]
- The ballot had ten questions: nine on provincial powers such as immigration and constitutional change, and a tenth on starting the independence process. [ 6 , 8 ]
- Premier Danielle Smith said Albertans chose a stronger Alberta within a united Canada. [ 8 , 10 ]
Confirmed by several sources
- The vote was held on 19 October and the independence proposal was effectively rejected, with about 77% backing staying in Canada in a partial count. [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ]
- Premier Danielle Smith said Albertans chose a stronger Alberta within a united Canada. [ 8 , 10 ]
- On 15 October, Prime Minister Mark Carney said the vote came at the worst time and that outside forces were trying to divide Canadians. [ 5 , 6 , 8 , 10 ]
- A separatist party, the Parti Quebecois, won Quebec's provincial election earlier in October. [ 4 , 5 , 6 ]
Still unclear
- The final result of the vote. The documents give only partial counts: about a third of ballots (more than 1 million) counted, with the result described as effectively decided.
- Whether the United States influenced the independence movement. Dong-A Ilbo, citing the Financial Times, said activist Jeff Rath met State Department officials three times, and the State Department said it made no promises; Yonhap said suspicions were raised in Canada, and Carney did not name the United States.
What local media are saying
Timeline, local time
- Voting opened in Alberta on 19 October. [ 4 ]
- Korea Economic Daily published a Reuters flash saying the referendum was rejected (20 October). [ 7 ]
- Chosun Ilbo reported that remain led with 76% to 77% in the early count (20 October). [ 8 ]
- Yonhap reported about 77% for staying with more than 1 million ballots counted (20 October). [ 10 ]